Last I checked, Sara Lee charges over $3 for her frozen pies. I don’t blame her. I’d charge $5. But when I make my own pies, it can cost as little as $1 and I know what ingredients I’m including. Plus I’m making mine with love and all that. (Priceless, no doubt.)
Making a frozen pie is as easy as making a not frozen pie. Not that making a pie is easy. Nor is it really hard. You just have to commit, you know? You have to be like, “Today I am going to mix together and roll out pie crusts. I’m just going to do it and get this job out of the way. Everyone will love the pie. It’s not as hard as it sounds. Let’s do this.”
Then, after you mix and roll your crusts, you add whatever filling you want (pumpkin, apple, etc). You wrap them well, and you freeze them.
This is exactly how Sara Lee does it. Only she puts hers in a box. We’ll skip that part.
This post is chuck full of pie-making tips, recipes, and instructions. Shall we begin?
How to Make a Whole Wheat Pie Crust
- 1¼ cup whole wheat flour
- ¼ teaspoon sea salt
- ⅓ cup Palm Shortening (or butter)
- 4-5 Tablespoons cold water
- Place flour, salt and shortening in food processor.
- Blend until shortening is cut throughout the flour and the mixture resembles crumbs.
- Drizzle in the water while the food processor is still whirling.
- Continue until a ball of dough forms.
- Roll out your dough into a circle on a well floured surface.
- Fold the circle in half. Then fold it in half again.
- Place your dough in your pie dish with the folded corner in the center.
- Unfold the dough, shape it into the dish and make the edges pretty. (see tutorial video below)
- Poke your dough a few times with a fork to keep it from poofing up in the oven.
- Bake at 450° for 10-12 minutes or until the crust is golden brown. Or, fill it with pie filling and bake as directed in specific pie recipe.
How to Shape a Pie Crust
You can look through a picture tutorial on this post to see the specifics of how to roll a pie crust and place it in a pie pan.
Want to watch me shaping a pie crust a few years ago? Watch the video below. (Click here if the video doesn’t show up for you.)
How to Make a Frozen Pie
To make a frozen pumpkin or fruit pie, make it according to the directions but do not bake. Wrap the unbaked pie very well in plastic wrap. You might even consider putting the wrapped pie into a freezer bag for extra freezer protection. Label the pie. Freeze for up to three months.
To bake your frozen pie, take it out of the freezer and put it directly into a cold oven. Turn on the oven and bake as directed allowing a little extra baking time if necessary. See how easy this is?!
If you plan to make a cream pie, bake your crust as directed, allow it to cool, then wrap and freeze. Thaw crust and add your cream filling before serving.
Holiday Pie Recipes
Pumpkin Pie Recipe
2 cups canned or frozen pumpkin
2/3 cup brown sugar or sucanat
1 teaspoon cinnamon
½ teaspoon ginger
½ teaspoon nutmeg
1 ¼ cup heavy cream
Whisk together all ingredients. Pour into unbaked pie crust. Freeze if desired. Bake at 350° for 50-60 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted in the middle of the pie comes out clean.
Apple Pie Recipe
5-6 apples (any variety)
1/4 cup sucanat or brown sugar
1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
Wash and slice apples. Stir in sucanat and cinnamon. Make a double pie crust recipe. Place one crust on the bottom of a pie pan. Spread apple pie filling into the unbaked crust. Place the second pie crust on top. Seal and shape as shown in the video above. Freeze if desired. Bake at 350° for 50-60 minutes.
I usually have prepared Apple Pie Filling in my freezer, making this super simple.
Dutch Apple Pie Recipe
Make as directed above, only make a single pie crust. Top apples with crumb topping recipe found here.
If you’re hoping to Get Ahead for the Holidays, I highly recommend making your pies soon and putting them into the freezer to pull out for easy baking the day before your meal!
Here are the quick links to all the recipes we covered in this series:
- Make-Ahead Turkey
- Stuffing Muffins
- Cheesy Mashed Potatoes
- Oh Good Gravy
- Green Bean Casserole
- How to Make Frozen Pies
- Simple Whipped Sweet Potatoes
- How to make Whipped Cream
- Whole Wheat Stir-and-Pour Dinner Rolls
Simple Meals is here! It’s saving my brain (and many of yours too!). If you haven’t joined yet, now’s the time. Get all the details here!
Melissa W says
Thanks for the information. I want to do this!
Thank you, I never knew how to freeze pumpkin pie , this is awesome!
Oh. That sounds yummy. And easy.
This is a great idea!! I can’t wait to fill my freezer with pies!! :)
Loving it! I am so glad you are doing this series.
Please clarify for me(I’m a bit slow at 3:45am), I make the filling–pour into unbaked crust–wrap really, really good–freeze, correct? Thanks!
I finally tried your recipe with palm shortening I bought a long time ago. It was so awesome! I’ve done all butter ones, but the palm shortening really was perfect. I may have to make a lot more pies now and maybe even freeze some :)
I am not much of a pie maker, but my husband is. I might try this sometime!
This sounds great. Homemade pies beat store-bought any day!
Such a great idea! I will try this and let you know how it goes!
Thanks for another great idea!
You must be way more dexterous (?) than I. I can’t imagine wrapping (well!) an unbaked pumpkin or sweet potato pie. Half of it will be on the floor on my way to the freezer, and the other half will likely be dribbling all over the other frozen foods once I get it in there. Do tell how you accomplish this miraculous feat.
I am planning on make ahead mashed potatoes, rolls, and desserts. Now I’m excited about Thanksgiving, otherwise known as the day that mom cooks and cleans all day long while everyone else watches football. Still grateful.
Try putting it on a cookie sheet and freezing it before wrapping it up. I do that sometimes to make it easier! :)
I was thinking the same thing! My deep freezer is 30 feet away, down 3 steps. There will be pumpkin all over everything!
That Dutch Apple Pie is calling my name….
I love this idea! Thanks for these holiday sress-savers!!!
Cathie – I intend to put my pumpkin pies (one with a crust and one without for the grain-free eaters) on a cookie sheet to freeze and THEN wrap it securely.
Jennifer Cummings says
Love making and freezing pie. It is just as easy to make two or three and freeze some.
This will help me a lot this year. Great post. Thanks!
Thank you for the information! I would love to win one of the gift certificates. Thank you.
Sarah Trattles says
Oh yum! If only someone would make crusts for me. I can fill all day, but can’t figure out the crusts. I’ll definitely be trying yours! Thanks Laura.
I’m with Cathie, though. I don’t have high hopes for my ability to wrap up a pie with liquid-y filling like pumpkin. I’m doing good if I can carry it from the counter to the oven without losing half of it!
This seems simple enough. Thanks!
Angela Wezowicz says
Cathie made me LOL. It’s all I can do to get a pumpkin pie to the oven…I’m usually praying on the way…
Question… do you usually cover the edges of your crust with foil when baking? B/c i find w/filling that is liquid, that step can be quite a bother/hassle, and just don’t do it anymore, I have found that crust is just fine if I leave it be.
Nope, I just leave it. Life’s too short. :)
Nathana Clay says
I am loving this series! It is not rocket science; yet it never occurred to me that I could prep so much ahead! I hate having to fight for counter space and oven space/timing when we host holidays/events. Any advice on pecan pie? Any chance it can be frozen? It is my favorite holiday pie. :)
Here’s my recipe for Pecan Pie, and yep, it can be frozen!
Dorthy M. says
This will definitely help. Hubby’s been after me to make an apple pie for Thanksgiving. Thank you!
I like making pies just can’t get one to turn out pretty. My mom and sister are so good at pies. I missed that gene. Can bake just about anything else–just not a pretty pie. Although my kids don’t complain. They don’t even know what a pretty pie looks like! As long as it is pumpkin with lots of chopped pecans on top, they are happy campers. Will have to try the freeze ahead–don’t have to eat so much pie at one time now either.
Rachel Anna says
This will make holiday dessert prep so much easier! Thanks for the tips and recipes!
Karen H. says
Good ideas! I have never tried making my own frozen pie, but I should try it sometime. Thank you!
I am so excited to start making my own frozen pies. Who knew it was so easy. Thanks Laura.
I’ve been freezing my baked pumpkin and pecan pies for years. They always taste fresh, and it sure saves time during the holidays.
I am so excited about making pies! I just got my nutrimill and can’t wait to make pie crust healthy!!! Thank you for the how to and encouragement.
My MIL asked me to bring an apple pie this year. Can’t wait to try out this one!
Mrs L says
Love that second paragraph…my sentiments exactly!
Never thought about freezing pies ahead of time. Thank you!
Thank you for this about the pies.Making food ahead of time is such a time saver.
The pie crust recipe is one of the worst I have ever tried. This is no fault of Laura’s. Some things just should not be made with whole wheat. Pie crust is one of them (yellow cake and pizza crust are included). I used hard white, freshly ground whole wheat and palm shortening. There was zero flavor and the crust was barely flaky. On the upside, it rolled out fine.
Perhaps whole wheat pastry flour would work better?
We hardly ever have pies, so I am going to stick to good, old white flour for the world’s best pie crust.
Bummer it didn’t work for you! I never have trouble with mine being flaky, even with hard white wheat. But trying ww pastry flour is a great idea!