I’m combining today and tomorrow because tomorrow is Sunday and it’s always hard enough getting all six of us ready and out the door for church on time without stopping to post pictures of sourdough starter. It just might push me over the edge to insanity. :)

This morning my starter didn’t have any liquid hanging around anywhere. I think it is because yesterday I started working to thicken my starter so that it wouldn’t be SO sour. If you remember, I only added 1/4 cup of water. I’m glad I did that. It’s getting to be more of the consistency I want it to be now.

Today was graduation day for us. (Oh, I couldn’t be more proud.)  My starter went from big glass jar to big glass bowl. I didn’t want sourdough overflowing all over the place.

Again today, I added a cup of flour and only 1/4 cup of liquid. Here is a picture of how thick my starter is now.

I layed a big piece of cheesecloth over my bowl without securing it with anything. 

On Day 7…just do the very same thing by adding 1 cup of flour and enough cold water to make your starter as thick (less sour) or as thin (more sour) as you want. I may try to pop back in briefly if I feel like there’s anything important I need to tell you about the Day 7 process.

And GUESS WHAT?! On Monday we can make BREAD!!! Would it surprise you to hear that the only ingredients you need to have ready to go are more flour and water…and some salt? (I use Redmonds Real Sea Salt.) 

Whoa-oa-oa! Get back! So much for the “sweetly sour” smell of my starter from yesterday morning. 

Shew!

A few of you commented that your starter was NOT smelling sweetly sour…but more like…well none of you said exactly. Although Cindy’s husband said that it smells like some of the calls he goes on (he is a fireman/paramedic).

May I suggest a description something like a cross between a dirty gym socks and baby spit up? Okay…so sorry. DON’T let this discourage you from making sourdough!!!!!  It gets better I promise! And…the sourdough bread doesn’t taste like the above mentioned descriptions. I PROMISE!

So…Day 5…if sniffing your sourdough starter makes you want to cough, gag, and run screaming from the room with tears running down your face…it’s doing exactly what it’s supposed to be doing. Good job creating a stinky masterpiece. :)

This morning a lot of liquid had risen to the top of my starter…and it had a frothy film on the top of the liquid. The froth was darker than yesterday and there was less of it. This is normal.

Elias saw this picture on my computer screen and said,
“Oh WEIRD…what IS that?” 
Oh how I love posting weird pictures on my blog…

So…a note about stinky…SOUR…sourdough:

The more liquidy and soupy your sourdough starter is…the more sour it is going to be/taste. Some people like their sourdough to have a very strong taste. My family and I don’t prefer it quite so sour.

Since this is Day 5 and there are only two days left before I make bread from my starter (woohoo!)…I decided today to start making my starter a little thicker to help with the over-sourness factor.

This morning I added one cup of flour as normal…but only 1/4 cup of water. I also poured off most of the liquid that had risen to the top again before adding the flour/water. As I stirred in the flour/water…it all mixed in just fine and was by no means too thick to stir. So, depending on how thick or runny your starter is at this point, you may want to adjust the amount of water you add. 

Several of you have asked if I would be sure to walk you through the sourdough bread making steps. ABSOLUTELY. I would NOT dare tell you how to make a sourdough starter and then leave you hanging about making the bread. It’s a tiny bit of a different process than making “yeast breads”…but it’s SO not hard to make. I’m getting so excited to finally be able to make my sourdough starter into bread! Yay!

So…anyone care to leave a description of how their sourdough is smelling by now?

Here’s what my jar of starter looked like this morning. 

 It is so exciting! When I stirred my flour into it yesterday, it was right at halfway full. 24 hours later..it has risen at least an inch if not more! And there are bubbles all through it. And I have this nice layer of froth on top. Yep…the sourdough starter is starting to become sourdough. 

You’ll notice in my top picture that I instead of the brown gooey liquid sitting on top of my starter like it had been on other days, it was at the bottom. I have no idea why…but it’s not a big deal. I just poured it all into a fresh jar just like that and it mixed back in. 

Jen was wondering why we need to transfer to a clean jar or bowl each day. I don’t know! My resources (Nourishing Traditions book…and my own past experiences with sourdough…and my trusty sourdough making friend, Anne)  just tell me to do it! I think the clean jar just gives your starter a fresh start as you feed it (or something like that?). If you just left it in the same container and just kept feeding it in that…all kinds of crud would build up on the sides and your jar would be all yucky. Then the sourdough would have to do it’s work around the yucky crud and it wouldn’t be as effective. Yes, I think that’s the reason why. :)

Okay, so again for Day 4…put your starter into a clean glass container, add a cup of flour and a cup of water, stir well, cover with cheesecloth and put in a warm place. 

I’m pretty sure tomorrow I’m going to need to transfer mine to my big glass bowl. It’s getting BIG! Oh, and it smells even more like sourdough today…just slightly…but I can tell it’s working.

By the way…yours might not be doing the exact thing mine is. Yours is working in YOUR air and in YOUR climate. Yours might be working faster…or slower than some of ours are working. 

I am curious what yours are looking like though. Did you have a layer of froth today? Do you see bubbles?! 

I kinda want to describe my sourdough smell as “sweetly sour”. Does that make sense? What does yours smell like?

Just getting started? Here are our previous sourdough starter days!

Read Day 1 and Day 2 to catch up!

This morning I didn’t have as much dark liquid on top of my starter as I did yesterday. Here’s what my jar looked like:

Have you been sniffing your jar?  I thought today mine smelled just a little tiny bit sour…just a little tiny bit. 

Today…do just like you did yesterday:  Pour off most of the liquid on top (I only had about a tablespoon today)…put your starter into a clean jar or glass bowl…add a cup of flour and a cup of water…stir it…replace the cheesecloth and put it back in it’s warm nest. Really, making sourdough takes no time at all. (Even including my jar sniffing time this process probably only took 2 minutes this morning.)

My jar is almost half full now…I may have to switch to a big glass bowl by the time these seven days are up!

And speaking of glass bowls…Jayme asked WHY it has to be glass? Can you use plastic bowls?

Sourdough should always be prepared in glass and baked in either glass or stoneware. Sourdough is acidic, therefore it will react with metal and plastic. It is very porous…so it will absorb the metalic or plastic-y tastes and qualities. For that matter…I try to always stir my sourdough with a wooden spoon. 

So…go sniff your jar…feed your sourdough…and come report back to us here about how your sourdough is doing! :)

In case you missed it…here is Sourdough Starter:  Day 1.

Here’s what my sourdough starter looked like after 24 hours. (It actually started separating and looking like this after only a few hours.)

I poured off the dark liquid that had risen to the top. Then I poured my starter in to a fresh, clean jar.

Once you have your starter in a clean jar or bowl, add 1 cup of whole wheat flour and almost 1 cup of cold water. Stir the flour in very well so that it is all moistened.

Replace your cheese cloth and rubber band…then put it back in your warm spot for 24 more hours. (Is this easy or what?!)

We’ll be repeating these same steps over the next several days. You have probably not noticed anything exciting happening to your sourdough starter yet. Still looks and smells like flour and water. Oh, but just wait!

For tomorrow you’ll need a clean jar or glass bowl, 1 cup whole wheat or rye flour and about a cup of cold water.

Here are a couple of FAQ I’ve been hearing from you about sourdough making…

• Sourdough bread is best baked in either glass or stone bread pans. Thought I should tell you that today so that if possible you can round up glass or stone pans for baking your sourdough bread.
• Some of you have expressed concern over having large enough jars for this process. If you can’t find half gallon jars (Try Ace Hardware if you have one close by. I ordered mine from Azure Standard.)…just use large glass bowls. That will work fine for this seven day process. Then…after you make your first batch of sourdough bread, the rest of your starter will fit just fine in a quart sized jar.

Thanks for joining me making sourdough!!